Car Totaled Not At Fault

Hundreds of Reviews
As seen on:
We don't get paid unless you do!
speak to an attorney now

Written by

Legally Reviewed by

In this article

Car is Totaled Not at Fault

If your car is totaled not at fault, and you’re wondering what your next steps should be, our car accident attorneys provide a straightforward breakdown of dealing with insurance claims, securing your rights for fair compensation, and understanding the necessary legal proceedings to ensure you don’t have to pay out of pocket for an accident you didn’t cause.

Key Takeaways

  • A car is considered totaled if the cost of repairs exceeds its value or it’s irreparable, with compensation based on pre-accident value, but may not cover the cost of a replacement vehicle of equal value.
  • After a not-at-fault accident, it’s crucial to ensure safety, document the scene, refrain from discussing fault, and promptly contact both your insurance provider and the at-fault driver’s insurer.
  • When a car is totaled and you’re not at fault, the claim process might involve liability insurance, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist insurance, which vary depending on at-fault parties and coverage type.

Understanding the "Totaled" Status

Illustration of a damaged car being towed away

The term “totaled car” might sound dramatic, but what does it really mean? A car is considered totaled if it is irreparable, or if the cost of repairs exceeds the car’s worth. When your car is declared totaled, your insurer compensates for the vehicle’s pre-accident value. However, it’s essential to remember that the insurance company’s payout does not guarantee that you can purchase a replacement vehicle of the same value.

The owner of a totaled car can choose to keep the vehicle, but it comes with a catch. The vehicle will receive a salvage title, and it must undergo repairs, inspection, and reinsurance to be roadworthy again. A salvage title indicates that the vehicle has suffered severe damage, and the repair costs would be close to or more than the vehicle’s value before the damage occurred.

Total Loss Definition

As daunting as it sounds, a total loss simply refers to a situation where a vehicle is considered irreparable, or the cost of repairing it is uneconomical compared to the vehicle’s value. But who makes this decision? Well, it’s typically the insurance companies. They compare the cost of repairs to the vehicle’s actual cash value or fair market value. They use what’s known as the Total Loss Formula, which equates the car’s Actual Cash Value (ACV) to the sum of the repair costs and the salvage value. This determination is made using resources like or Kelley Blue Book to estimate the car’s fair market value.

Factors Affecting the Totaled Decision

Now you might wonder, “What factors influence the decision to declare a car as totaled?” Well, two crucial factors play a significant role: the actual cash value of the vehicle and the repair costs. If the cost of repairs is approaching or exceeding the car’s actual cash value, the vehicle is typically declared totaled.

It’s essentially a cost-benefit analysis to determine if repairing the vehicle is financially justifiable compared to its value.

Steps to Take Immediately After a Not-at-Fault Accident

Imagine the chaotic aftermath of a car accident. Amidst the confusion, there are immediate steps to take to ensure your safety and protect your right to fair compensation. Here are the steps to follow:

  1. Ensure everyone’s safety. If it’s safe to do so, move the vehicle and call 911, regardless of the accident’s severity.
  2. Reporting the accident to the police is essential to secure official documentation necessary for insurance claims.
  3. At the accident scene, it’s crucial to refrain from discussing who is at fault or making apologies, as this could be interpreted as an admission of liability.

Following the initial response, it’s time to gather information. Compile a checklist of details to record at the scene, including personal contact information, insurance details, and specifics about the vehicles involved. Remember to exchange and document personal and insurance information with all third parties involved in the accident without admitting or discussing fault.

Lastly, promptly contact both your insurance company and the at-fault driver’s insurer.

Assess Your Health and Safety

The adrenaline rush following a car accident can often mask the severity of any injuries. Therefore, it’s crucial to prioritize your health and safety and seek immediate medical attention, even if you think you’re not injured. Checking for injuries among all passengers is vital, and emergency services must be called immediately if there are any injuries.

Document the Accident Scene

Illustration of a person taking photos of a car accident scene

Once the dust has settled, it’s time to put on your detective hat. Documenting the accident scene is crucial to preserving evidence. Take photos of the accident scene, including any injuries and damages, and obtain witness statements if possible.

Remember, your own insurance company may require a detailed account of the accident and can request evidence such as photographs and police reports to ascertain responsibility.

Notify Relevant Insurance Companies

As soon as the immediate aftermath of the accident is managed and you’ve gathered all the necessary information, it’s time to notify the relevant insurance companies. Prompt contact with your insurance carrier is crucial to ensure the timely initiation of the claims process. Provide your insurer with all pertinent information regarding the accident as soon as possible.

Don’t forget to include the at-fault driver’s insurance details to facilitate the claim. It’s also necessary to report the accident to the at-fault driver’s insurance company, which your insurer can help coordinate.

Understanding Insurance Coverage Options

Now, let’s delve into the insurance coverage maze. Compensation for a totaled car largely depends on who is at fault and the type of insurance claim. Several types of insurance coverage may apply in a not-at-fault accident, including liability insurance, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist insurance. But what do these terms mean, and how do they come into play in a not-at-fault accident?

Liability insurance covers damages to others but not your own vehicle. In other words, if your car is totaled and you’re not at fault, the responsible party’s liability insurance may cover the damages. On the other hand, collision coverage pays for damages to your own car, regardless of who is at fault in the accident. Lastly, uninsured motorist insurance comes into play when the at-fault driver lacks sufficient insurance coverage. It provides compensation for your losses in such scenarios.

Liability Insurance

Liability insurance, including property liability coverage, is the basic coverage that every driver must have as part of their car insurance policy. It covers damages that you inflict on others in an accident, but it doesn’t cover damages to your own vehicle. This means that if your car is totaled in an accident and you’re not at fault, the at-fault driver’s liability insurance should cover the damages to your vehicle.

Collision Coverage

Illustration of a car collision

Unlike liability insurance, own collision coverage pays for damages to your own car, regardless of who is at fault in the accident. This coverage includes repair costs that exceed the deductible and may cover the full value of the car if it’s declared a total loss.

If you have collision coverage and your financed car is totaled, you can file a claim with your insurance, irrespective of who is at fault.

Uninsured Motorist Insurance (UIM)

Unfortunately, not all drivers on the road have sufficient insurance. What happens when the at-fault driver lacks sufficient insurance coverage to pay for the costs of an accident? That’s where uninsured motorist insurance (UIM) comes into play. UIM provides compensation when an at-fault driver lacks sufficient insurance coverage to pay for the costs of an accident, such as when the driver is uninsured or underinsured.

Navigating the Insurance Claim Process

After understanding the types of insurance coverage and who is at fault, the next step is to navigate the insurance claim process. This process includes filing a claim, determining fault, and negotiating settlements. And yes, it can be as complex as it sounds, but fear not. We’re here to guide you through it.

To file an insurance claim for a totaled car when not at fault, it’s essential to promptly contact both your insurance company and the at-fault driver’s insurer. The claim must include all necessary documentation, such as proof of accident-related losses, the car title, repair bills, professional damage assessments, details concerning the car loan, and actual cash value (ACV) research.

Now, determining fault can be a complex process. Insurance companies conduct their own investigations to establish fault in an accident. If necessary, they may attempt to recoup costs from the at-fault party’s insurance provider through a process called subrogation.

Lastly, negotiating successfully with insurance adjusters involves presenting clear and factual information about the accident rather than focusing on accusations.

Filing a Claim

Filing an insurance claim may seem daunting, but it’s a crucial step in getting compensation for your totaled car. To file a claim, promptly contact both your car insurance company and the at-fault driver’s insurer. Provide them with all pertinent information regarding the accident as soon as possible.

This information includes details about the accident, damage to your vehicle, medical bills, and other accident-related losses.

Determining Fault

Determining fault in a car accident often involves a complex process of investigation by insurance companies. They assess:

  • evidence
  • witness statements
  • police reports
  • sometimes even hire accident reconstruction experts

The insurance provider of the driver responsible for the accident typically covers the expenses related to the accident, including compensation for the totaled vehicle.

If there are false claims of fault, a lawyer can assist in refuting these by reviewing evidence and potentially hiring accident reconstruction experts.

Negotiating Settlements

Once fault is determined, the negotiation of settlements begins. Insurance companies may offer to find a replacement vehicle for the one totaled or provide a cash settlement based on the comparable values in the local market. If the offered settlement does not satisfactorily compensate for the damages incurred, you have the right to negotiate for a higher amount or even consider taking legal action for fair compensation.

Financial Considerations After a Totaled Car Accident

Illustration of a person discussing financial matters with an insurance agent

Having a car totaled in an accident can bring about significant financial considerations, especially if you still owe money on a car loan. The insurance company is required to pay the car’s actual cash value (ACV) of the totaled car, but the total amount is also subjected to the policy limits put in place. If the fair market value of the totaled car is less than the loan balance, you, as the owner, are responsible for the difference unless you have gap insurance.

With the payout from the insurance company, you might wonder if it’s time to purchase a new vehicle. If a new car purchase is necessary, the loan for the totaled vehicle may be consolidated into a new loan arrangement, requiring careful consideration of loan terms and financial planning.

Outstanding Car Loans

When your financed vehicle is totaled, the financial implications can be quite significant. You are legally required to pay off the remaining balance on your car loan. Some options to consider include:

  • Paying off the remaining balance in full
  • Negotiating with your lender for a reduced payoff amount
  • Using insurance proceeds to pay off the loan
  • Rolling over the outstanding balance into the financing of a new vehicle

However, these options require careful consideration of loan terms and financial planning.

Gap Insurance

If your car’s actual cash value is less than the amount you owe on your loan, you’re left with a gap that you’re responsible for. This is where gap insurance comes in. Gap insurance is designed to cover the difference between the totaled car’s actual cash value and the remaining loan amount.

It can help cover the financial gap between the car’s actual cash value (ACV) and the remaining balance on the loan, ensuring you’re not left in a financial lurch.

Purchasing a New Vehicle

Illustration of a person purchasing a new car at a dealership

After settling the financial matters of your totaled car, you might be in the market for a new vehicle. The insurance payout, after settling the totaled vehicle’s loan balance, can help finance the purchase of a new car. Remember, purchasing a new car is a significant financial decision, and it’s vital to consider factors such as the cost, financing options, and your budget.

Disputing Insurance Valuations

You’ve filed the claim, and the insurance company has come back with a valuation for your totaled car. But what if you disagree with it? You have the right to dispute the insurer’s valuation. You can request a ‘total loss valuation report’ from your insurance company, which provides detailed comparison data used to determine the car’s value.

If you disagree with the insurer’s value, you can employ an independent appraiser to prepare a report that may challenge the insurance company’s valuation. For vehicles that had improvements, repairs, or customizations, presenting meticulous documentation is crucial to ensure that the insurance claim covers the full value of the car.

If disputes with an insurer cannot be resolved through negotiation, hiring a lawyer might be necessary to gather additional evidence, provide legal arguments, or potentially sue in civil court.

Dealing with DMV Procedures

Once the dust settles and you’ve navigated through the insurance claims process, there are still a few administrative tasks to take care of. One of these includes dealing with the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV). After accepting a total loss payout, the car’s title must be transferred to the insurance company. Depending on the state’s laws, the title transfer may need to be notarized.

In addition to transferring the title, you’ll need to cancel the registration of the totaled vehicle. Here are the steps to follow:

  1. Contact your local DMV office.
  2. Submit the required form along with proof that the vehicle is no longer in your possession.
  3. Some states may require you to surrender the vehicle’s license plates before they will allow the cancellation of the registration.
  4. Don’t forget to return your license plates to the DMV after canceling your registration. It’s an important step to complete the process.

Seeking Legal Assistance

Navigating through insurance claims and disputing valuations can be a daunting task. That’s where a car accident lawyer can be beneficial. A car accident lawyer can guide you through the claims process, assist in negotiating with insurance companies for a fair settlement, and provide legal advice.

If you haven’t been offered a fair settlement for your totaled vehicle, a car accident lawyer should be consulted. Remember, lawyers often operate on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only collect fees if they win your case or achieve a settlement.


Navigating the aftermath of a car accident where your vehicle is totaled and you’re not at fault can be overwhelming. From understanding the totaled status and insurance coverage options to dealing with DMV procedures and disputing insurance valuations, every step is crucial to ensuring you receive fair compensation. With the right knowledge and guidance, the journey through this complex process becomes more manageable. Remember, don’t hesitate to seek legal assistance if you need advice or help in negotiating with insurance companies. Above all, drive safe and stay insured.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean when a car is considered totaled?

When a car is considered totaled, it means that it is either irreparable or the cost of repairs exceeds the car's worth. In this case, the insurance company compensates for the vehicle's pre-accident value, which may not be enough to purchase a replacement of similar value.

What steps should I take immediately after a not-at-fault accident?

After a not-at-fault accident, prioritize safety, call 911, and gather information for insurance, but avoid discussing fault at the scene. Contact both your insurance company and the at-fault driver's insurer promptly.

What is gap insurance, and how can it help me?

Gap insurance can help by covering the difference between your car's actual cash value and the remaining loan amount if your vehicle is totaled and the value is less than what you owe. This can provide financial protection in the event of a total loss.

How can a car accident lawyer assist me in the process?

A car accident lawyer can assist you by guiding you through the claims process, negotiating with insurance companies, and providing legal advice. It's essential to consult a lawyer if you haven't received a fair settlement for your totaled vehicle.

For a free legal consultation, call

(800) 345-HURT
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form
Call (800) 345-HURT or complete a Free Case Evaluation form

frequently asked questions

No items found...
Connect with a J & J INJURY ATTORNEYS Expert Using a Single Click
Thank you! Your submission has been received!

One of our attorneys will reach out to you shortly

For Immediate assistance
dial 800-345-4878
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Car Accident Realted Articles

No items found.