How Much Does Insurance Increase After an Accident?

Hundreds of Reviews
As seen on:
We don't get paid unless you do!
speak to an attorney now

Written by

Legally Reviewed by

In this article

How Much Does Insurance Increase After an Accident?

Experiencing a car accident comes with immediate worries, one of which is ‘how much does insurance increase after an accident?’ Typically, drivers face an $840 average hike in annual premiums. However, factors like accident severity, your driving history, and specific policy details complicate the answer. Our car accident attorneys explore these nuances and provide clear expectations for your post-accident insurance costs in the following sections.

Key Takeaways

  • At-fault car accidents generally lead to an average increase of $840 in annual full coverage car insurance rates due to the higher risk profile of the drivers, with variability based on factors like state laws, driving history, and insurance provider policies.
  • Car insurance premiums can be affected by no-fault accidents, potentially increasing by 10% or more depending on the insurer and the driver’s history of claims, even in cases where the driver is not to blame.
  • Insurance rates typically increase for three to five years post-accident with the exact duration influenced by state-specific regulations, and drivers can employ strategies like seeking competitive quotes, adjusting deductibles, and maximizing discounts to mitigate insurance rate increases.

Exploring the Impact of At-Fault Accidents on Car Insurance Premiums

Illustration of two cars in a collision

If you’re at fault in a car accident, brace yourself for the potential financial hit. On average, full coverage car insurance rates increase by $840 after such an incident. This increase in car insurance costs is due to the higher risk assessment for drivers involved in at-fault accidents, who statistically are more likely to be involved in future traffic violations.

Yet, the impact on your wallet can vary. Your state of residence and the insurance provider you’re with can significantly affect the auto insurance rate increase. Furthermore, drivers can mitigate the increase in insurance costs, potentially lessening the impact by an average of $872 per year by utilizing various discounts available from insurance providers.

The Role of State Regulations and Insurance Providers

State laws and insurance providers play pivotal roles in determining how much your insurance premium may increase after an at-fault accident. Some factors that can affect the increase in your premium include:

  • The severity of the accident
  • Your driving history
  • Your insurance provider’s policies
  • The state you live in

It’s important to note that some states have regulations that limit the percentage by which a state and insurance company can raise premiums following an at-fault accident, offering some protection for drivers.

On the other hand, insurance companies use proprietary algorithms to determine the rate increase after an accident. These algorithms consider factors such as:

  • the policyholder’s driving history
  • the severity of the accident
  • claims history
  • state-specific adjustments

These factors are taken into account to calculate the rate increase.

Severity of the Accident and Its Effect on Rates

It’s not just who is at fault that matters; the severity of the accident can greatly influence insurance premiums. For instance, incidents involving serious injury and extensive property damage can lead to a substantial increase in car insurance rates.

Unfortunately, there’s no magic formula to predict the exact impact of an accident on your insurance rates. But being aware that the severity of an accident can play a significant role in the rate increase prepares you for the potential financial implications.

Consequences of No-Fault Accidents on Auto Insurance Rates

Illustration of a car with a broken headlight

It’s a common misconception that if you’re not at fault in an accident, your insurance rates won’t be affected. However, insurance premiums may still be impacted after a no-fault accident, with some companies raising rates by 10% or more.

While state laws such as those in Oklahoma and California prohibit insurers from raising rates for such incidents, insurance companies may increase rates for drivers who have a history of multiple claims, viewing them as high-risk, regardless of fault. So, even if you’re the innocent party in an accident, be aware that it may still affect your insurance rates.

Duration of an Accident's Influence on Your Insurance Record

Illustration of a calendar with 3-5 years marked

An accident doesn’t just bump up your insurance rates in the short term; it can have long-lasting effects too. Typically, insurance rates increase for three to five years after an at-fault accident. However, the specific time period can differ based on the state’s regulations where the accident occurred.

For instance, in states like California, accidents remain on a driving record for about three years, while in Michigan, most at-fault accidents are recorded for seven years. For accurate, state-specific information, it’s best to consult with your state’s Department of Motor Vehicles.

Deciding Whether to File an Insurance Claim Post-Accident

Deciding whether to file an insurance claim after an accident can be a tough call. If a minor accident involves only you and your car, such as hitting a stationary object, managing repairs out of pocket could save you from a potential insurance premium increase. Considering insurance after an accident is essential to make an informed decision, especially when the insurance company pays for the damages.

However, in the case of an accident with another driver, even if the damage seems minor, there are factors to consider. Trust level with the other driver is crucial, as there’s a risk they may file an insurance claim later, despite an initial agreement to handle the matter privately. It’s also critical to get a mechanic’s accurate repair estimate to ensure no hidden damages are missed that could incur additional unforeseen expenses.

Navigating Accident Forgiveness Coverage Options

Illustration of a shield protecting a car from a rate increase arrow

Accident forgiveness can be a game-changer in maintaining stable insurance premiums after an accident. This optional coverage prevents car insurance premiums from increasing after the first accident.

However, not everyone is eligible. Drivers with good driving records can often access this coverage, but the guidelines and availability vary by insurance provider and state. While it can result in additional costs, this coverage provides the benefit of avoiding a premium increase after the policyholder’s first at-fault accident.

Strategies to Mitigate Higher Auto Insurance Rates Post-Accident

Despite the many factors that can lead to higher insurance rates after an accident, there are strategies to mitigate these increases. These include shopping for competitive quotes, adjusting your deductible, and maximizing policy discounts.

Shopping for Competitive Auto Insurance Quotes

Seeking out competitive auto insurance quotes is critical, especially after an accident. High-risk drivers, for instance, can particularly benefit from shopping around, as their premiums are likely to increase.

Remember, the goal when shopping around is to find the best combination of coverage and affordable rates to suit your specific situation. Continual evaluation of insurance options, especially after a rise in premiums, ensures ongoing financial optimization.

Adjusting Your Deductible for Savings

Another strategy is to increase your deductible, which can reduce your monthly premium. If you raise your deductible to $1,000, for instance, you could potentially offset a rate increase by requiring more out-of-pocket expenses per claim.

Bear in mind, though, that if you opt for a higher deductible, it’s crucial to ensure you have sufficient emergency funds to cover the out-of-pocket expense before insurance applies.

Maximizing Discounts for Auto Insurance Policies

Maximizing discounts can also help offset an increase in insurance premiums. For instance, Accident Forgiveness discounts can be earned through consistent safe driving over time or by maintaining a clean driving record with no accidents for a set period, such as five years.

Other discounts that might be granted to drivers include:

  • Completing defensive driving or driver education courses, which not only offer a premium reduction but also enhance driver safety
  • Multi-policy discounts
  • Multi-car discounts
  • Specific occupational discounts

These discounts can help you save money on your auto insurance, especially when offered by most auto insurance companies.

The Long-Term View: Building a Clean Driving Record

While strategies can help in the short term, keeping a clean driving record is key to long-term savings on auto insurance premiums. A clean driving record can lead to significant savings, with savings averaging $289 annually compared to the national average.

A clean driving record typically spans a period of three to seven years without any violations or accidents, with the exact timeframe varying by state. Less serious offenses such as speeding tickets may be removed from a driving record after a certain period, often three years, while more severe infractions like DUIs can remain for much longer or even permanently.

High Risk Drivers: Finding Suitable Auto Insurance Coverage

Being labeled a high-risk driver isn’t the end of the road. Yes, insurance companies may increase your insurance rates by 50-100%, and you may experience restrictions in your coverage options. But specialty insurers such as USAA, State Farm, and GEICO may offer more competitive rates for high-risk drivers.

By maintaining a good payment history, high-risk drivers who secure coverage through companies specializing in high-risk auto insurance may see their rates decrease over time. It’s all about finding the right provider and maintaining a good relationship with them.

After the Incident: Next Steps with Your Car Insurance Policy

After an accident, knowing the right steps to take can make a significant difference. Contacting the police is critical as they will document the scene and generate a report, which may be required for the insurance claim process. It’s also important to exchange insurance information and contact details with the other involved parties.

Promptly notifying your insurance provider and commencing the claims process is also recommended. Depending on your state’s requirements, you may also need to report the accident to the DMV, especially if there are injuries or significant damage.


To sum up, understanding how accidents impact your car insurance rates and the factors that contribute to these increases can help you navigate post-accident financial recovery. Whether you’re at fault or not, an accident can lead to increased insurance premiums. Yet, various factors, from state regulations to the severity of the accident, can influence the extent of this increase.

However, there are strategies to mitigate these increases, from shopping around for competitive quotes to maximizing policy discounts and maintaining a clean driving record. Remember, every situation is unique, so what works for one person may not work for another. It’s all about finding the strategy that suits you best and helps maintain your financial stability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does your insurance go up after a claim that is not your fault?

Yes, your insurance can go up after a claim that is not your fault, depending on the circumstances of the accident, the types of coverage you have, and your claims history. It's not always guaranteed that rates won't increase.

How much can my insurance rates increase after an at-fault accident?

On average, full coverage car insurance rates can increase by $840 after an at-fault accident, but the actual increase can vary based on state regulations and the insurance company's policies. Be sure to review your specific policy to understand the potential impact on your rates.

Can a no-fault accident affect my insurance rates?

Yes, a no-fault accident can lead to an increase in insurance rates, especially if the driver has a history of multiple claims. It's important to drive carefully to avoid such increases in insurance premiums.

How long does an accident impact my insurance rates?

An accident can impact your insurance rates for three to five years, with variations based on state regulations.

What is Accident Forgiveness coverage, and how can it help me?

Accident Forgiveness coverage prevents your car insurance premiums from increasing after the first accident, but it's important to check with your insurance provider for eligibility and guidelines.

For a free legal consultation, call

(800) 345-HURT
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form
Call (800) 345-HURT or complete a Free Case Evaluation form

frequently asked questions

No items found...
Connect with a J & J INJURY ATTORNEYS Expert Using a Single Click
Thank you! Your submission has been received!

One of our attorneys will reach out to you shortly

For Immediate assistance
dial 800-345-4878
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Car Accident Realted Articles

No items found.